Matthew 10:16-22
EASP Chapel, Candler School of Theology
October 21, 2026 | Evening Prayer, Feast of Saint James of Jerusalem
Neil Reilly, SSB
This week the Church remembers James of Jerusalem, brother of our Lord. Scripture and tradition tell us that James was not a follower of his brother, and only converted later, after the resurrection. With today’s Gospel in mind, we can’t really blame him for his suspicious attitude towards the gospel. Perhaps James was trying to avoid being “dragged before governors and kings,” “handed over to councils” and “flogged in the synagogues.” If James was present when Jesus delivered today’s message, it must have felt personal. “Sibling will betray sibling to death.” For James, that had to hit close to home.
Perhaps James remembered these harsh words when he heard the news that his estranged brother had been killed. Perhaps that’s what drew him to Jerusalem where scripture tells us Jesus appeared to him, and that he was with the disciples in the upper room. If that’s the case, James did not convert because today’s Gospel turned out not to be true. On the contrary, he saw the truth of it plainly. His own brother “handed over,” “dragged before governors,” and “betrayed to death” by friends.
Perhaps more than anyone, James had been running from this gospel his whole life! And here it was, the worst of it, on display! But somehow, James heard it as good news. For some reason, after the slaughter of his brother, like a sheep by wolves James chose to follow the one who says: “See, I am sending you out like sheep into the midst of wolves.”
✦
It’s easy to imagine that Jesus’ friends and followers knew James, or knew about him. And James would have known some of them, at least those from around their home. I wonder what they thought about each other. Jesus’ flesh-and-blood brother, and his new family, found on the road to the kingdom. I wonder how Jesus’ friends felt when, after Jesus’ resurrection, James showed up singing a different tune. Did they treat him like a wolf? A sheep? A serpent? A dove?
His arrival must have been a disturbance! It would be reasonable for people to feel threatened, wary of James’ motives. Was it wise to accept him? Innocent? Many of them, like all of us, would have preferred things to stay steady and stable I’m sure. They’d prefer to keep the company they kept, and the rules they had. They’d be frightened by the change brought by newcomers like James, and certainly by the change James eventually blessed in accepting the mission to the gentiles. Who wouldn’t prefer a risk-free world, unending comfort in the familiar.
But that is not the Gospel message. Jesus sent his friends like “sheep into the midst of wolves.” And his friends, like us, were challenged to hear that as good news. Challenged to recognize the awesome trust that Jesus has put in us. Being sent like “sheep into the midst of wolves” is not a threat. It is a charge! See, Jesus says, I am sending you to change the way things are done! I intend to turn the world upside down with your gifts! Your wisdom, your innocence.
James’ conversion is precisely this: accepting the call of Jesus to proclaim the gospel, fully aware of how destabilizing it can, and should be. And James’ conversion should remind us that we can only do this with Jesus. “Do not worry about how you are to speak or what you are to say…for it is not you who speak, but the Spirit of your Father speaking through you.” It can be easy, in the midst of wolves, whether it’s an existential threat or just a vestry meeting, to miss this critical piece of Jesus’ message. If James lived his whole life next to Jesus and missed that he was God, I’m sure we all will sometimes as well.
We must make room for God. Get out of the way of ourselves, and let God work within us. When we do, God will do unexpected things, wonderful things. “The wolf and the lamb shall feed together!” Tradition tells us that, in the end, James met the fate our gospel today describes: persecuted and martyred for Jesus’ sake. We can take comfort, I think, from the fact that he “endured to the end” for the love of his brother.
As we face whatever trials answering Jesus’ call may bring us, I pray that we will face them with the wisdom of serpents and the innocence of doves. And I pray we may face them like James, certain of the help and presence of Jesus, our brother.
Blessed James, Brother of our Lord, Pray for us.