John 17:18–23
Saint James’ Church, Madison Avenue
November 4, 2026 | Wednesday Eucharist (Richard Hooker)
Neil Reilly, SSB
Our siblings in most other Protestant denominations define themselves by their doctrines, “confessions of faith” that outline what they believe. These confessions define what it means to follow Jesus in their particular way. In that sense… To be Presbyterian means to confess that the contents of the Westminster Confession are true. To be Lutheran means to follow the tenets of the Augsburg Confession. To be Congregational means to build one’s belief system on the Savoy Declaration. To be Methodist means to teach according to Wesley’s Articles of Religion.
If you were to visit every Presbyterian, Lutheran, Congregational, or Methodist church in New York City, you might not be able to tell which was which from the way they worship on Sunday morning. Some Presbyterian churches may be more different from each other than they are from Methodist churches! But if you asked what they believe, they’d be able to reference these confessions: doctrinal standards that often sit at the center of their constitutions and their life as disciples of Jesus.
Though Anglicans have written a great deal about what we believe, there has never been a doctrinal statement you have to sign on to be a member. And if you were to go to every Episcopal church in New York City and ask folks what they believe, you’d get a broad set of answers! But chances are that, unlike with our Protestant siblings, you would immediately recognize that these churches were part of the same tradition. Instead of doctrines, we are held together by our worship. By the Book of Common Prayer.
✦
Today, in the Gospel of John, we hear Jesus’ great prayer for his friends and for the church: “That they all may be one.” At the Last Supper, Jesus prayed that, just as he is in the Father and the Father is in him, so also we might be in God.
Other denominations have, faithfully, hoped to answer this prayer with a definition of what it means to be Christian. Their confessions were written as a tool to define what was required for belonging. Anglicans, from the very beginning, have tried to answer Jesus’ prayer that we all might be one with common prayer.
✦
Richard Hooker, who we remember today, was part of the first generation to grow up in the Anglican common prayer tradition. When he was born, the English Reformation had already begun, and the first Book of Common Prayer had appeared five years before. By the time he came of age, there were lots of different ideas about how to be the Church in England. Without the doctrinal definitions that continental reformers had provided, Christians in England argued over what, precisely, it was that they believed. How do we know Jesus? How is he present in the sacraments? What are sacraments?! These were live questions, and each group wanted the church and her beliefs to conform more closely to their personal understanding of what was right; some even wanted a statement of belief like their siblings on the Continent.
In many ways, we have Richard Hooker to thank for the way Anglicans held together. Hooker explained that the church was defined by participation. The church was not only the people who believed the right things or acted the right way; it was the whole of society gathered together around Jesus. Just as Genesis describes God forming Eve from Adam’s side, so Hooker said that the church was formed out of the side of Jesus, opened in the crucifixion. And so, as Adam and Eve could say to one another, Christ and the church can look at each other and say, “This at last is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh.”
To answer Jesus’ prayer that we might be one, all that is truly required, according to Hooker, is participation in this mystery, the church. Following Jesus is not reducible to a formulary, the details of which we will inevitably disagree over. Following Jesus, and being in him as he is in us, is best expressed by common prayer. Against those who wanted a sharper definition of the faith, Hooker didn’t propose a compromise; he invited us into the corporate action of prayer which makes us, as we pray in the Rite I postcommunion prayer, “very members incorporate in the mystical body” of Christ.
✦
Though divisions between denominations or church parties no longer make headlines, we live today in a time of divisions, when Jesus’ prayer that we all might be one seems like a distant fantasy. It is tempting, and sometimes right, to define what it is we will stand for, what we will tolerate and what we will not, and to build our community around our identity and the details of our personal convictions.
The life and work of Richard Hooker reminds us that this is not how Jesus expects us to answer his prayer. We will never, by our own efforts, achieve the unity he prayed for. But we can move toward this unity by walking toward Jesus, from wherever we might stand. We can only see Jesus, only move toward him, when we seek a common prayer and indeed a common life, even and perhaps especially with those we might not agree with. For Hooker, the church needed no doctrinal definition stronger than “one Lord, one faith, one baptism.” God, not humanity, is the source of unity.
Today, the day after a consequential Election Day, we have a particular opportunity to live into this kind of unity. Common life in the body of Christ does not require surrendering our truly held beliefs to compromise with our enemies. Instead, it imagines, confidently, that those beliefs might change as we walk toward Jesus with our neighbors.
Let us pray, as we come to the Table today, that God grant us the courage given to Richard Hooker, that we might commit to a truly common life and be an answer to Jesus’ prayer that we all might be one.