Matthew 21:23-32
Saint Peter’s Westchester Square
September 27, 2026 | Eucharist
Neil Reilly, SSB
“By what authority are you doing these things?” This is the question the chief priests and the elders of the people ask Jesus. They want to know about the things Jesus is doing. Jesus has been in the Temple these last few days, in the place they, the chief priests and the elders of the people, have authority, and he’s been doing a lot. He’s been saying things, too, but that doesn’t seem to be what they’re concerned with. They’re more interested in the healing and the flipping tables.
And they want to know: “By what authority are you doing these things?” Jesus, who never seems to give a straight answer if he can help it, answers with a question: By what authority did John do the things he did? Jesus has trapped them — they know they can’t answer honestly. John was very popular. If they tell the truth, which is that they think John did the things he did by an authority from earth, the crowd will riot. It will threaten their authority. If they lie, and say John did the things he did by an authority from heaven, they’ll be handing over power. It will threaten their authority. So they refuse to answer, they tell him “we do not know.” Jesus refuses right back: “Neither will I tell you by what authority I am doing these things.”
✦
Quite a lot of talk about authority, and about doing.
To drive the point home, Jesus tells them a parable. A father has two sons who he sends to go and do work in the vineyard. The first says no, rudely. “I will not.” The second says yes, very politely. “I go, sir.” But, as we all know, and is very common in Matthew’s gospel, there is a reversal. The first son, the rude son, “changed his mind” and goes to the vineyard, he does the work his father asked of him. The second son, despite his words of promise, did not do the work.
Jesus asks the chief priests and the elders of the people: “Which of the two did the will of his father?” This time there’s no way out, there’s only one possible answer: “The first,” they tell him. It is in the doing of the will, not simply the saying, that one properly responds to the father’s authority. And Jesus clearly thinks they’ve come up short. Jesus tells them, in one of the most memorable lines in all of scripture, “the tax collectors and the prostitutes are going into the kingdom of God ahead of you… because you did not change your mind and believe.”
✦
In a certain sense, this parable is basically common sense. Do what you say and say what you do. All of us prefer people who follow through on what they commit to. We all think, deep down, that, though it’s the thought that counts, showing up counts a bit more than thinking about showing up. Is that what Jesus is telling chief priests and the elders of the people today? Is that what he’s telling us? It only matters what you do? That we go to work in the vineyard, even if we say we won’t. That we live moral lives, ethical lives. Regardless of what we believe. That it doesn’t really matter if we listen to the father, as long as we, more or less, do the father’s work.
I think Jesus is, in fact, pleased when we do good work. He cares deeply about the state of the world and the quality of our relationships, and so what we do, whatever the reason, matters deeply to him. But I don’t think that’s what today’s parable is about. Because today’s parable starts with a question: By what authority are you doing these things? Jesus is, indeed, teaching us about what we should do. But he is also teaching us about authority. About obedience.
✦
There are two words for “listen” in Latin. Both of them have English derivatives, so you’ll recognize them I think. The first is “audire.” It means “to listen” and also “to hear.” It’s where we get “audio,” “audible” and “audience.” The second is “obedire.” It means “to listen,” as well, though in its most technical sense it means “to listen towards.” It’s here we get “obedience.” So you might “audire” to some music, but you “obedire” your elders. You “audire” to the waves crashing against the shore, but you “obedire” to God.
Obedience, in this sense, is to listen not only to hear, not only to experience, not only to understand, but to listen ready to change. This is what the first son did. “‘Son, go and work in the vineyard today.’ He answered, ‘I will not,’ but later he changed his mind and went.” Jesus is speaking here not principally about doing for doings-sake. Jesus is speaking of faith. Faith that is inseparable from doing, because it is transformative. A faith that is total trust in Jesus’s authority.
✦
Where can we learn this trust? My order, as many of you know, is named after three siblings who trusted Jesus uniquely. Martha, Mary and Lazarus. In the eleventh chapter of John’s gospel, Lazarus dies. Jesus comes to Bethany, to the home of Martha, Mary and Lazarus.
He is greeted by a grieving and angry Martha. “Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died. But even now I know that God will give you whatever you ask of him.” Jesus asks her if she believes in him and what his life means for Lazarus. She answers, “Yes, Lord, I believe.” Next Jesus meets a grieving and overwhelmed Mary, who says “Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died.” Seeing his friend weeping, Jesus wept. Both of these sisters trust Jesus totally. And Jesus meets them exactly where they are. He argues when Martha argues, he weeps when Mary weeps. This is his response to their faith and obedience.
Finally, Jesus comes to the grave of his friend, perhaps his best friend, Lazarus. Here we see the most perfect display of faith and obedience in the whole of the gospels. Here, from Lazarus, we see doing wrapped up in transformation as in no other instance. Jesus stands at the entrance of his friend’s grave and says in a loud voice, “Lazarus, come out!” And he does. He listens with “obedire” ears and undergoes the greatest of changes, from death to life.
In Jesus’ friends, we see an example of how we might approach the obedience that Jesus calls us to. Faith in Jesus, Trust in Jesus. Hearing Jesus’ words and Doing what Jesus asks them to do. By what authority are they doing these things? Jesus’. We see that faith is not simply what we say or what we do, but what we live. Or as Calvin put it, it is “not a subscription to true doctrine, but something deeper,” it is the realization that we must “deny ourselves and commit our whole lives to God.” The wonderful reality is that God has done this for us in the person of Jesus.
As we heard in the hymn of Christ’s humility in Philippians. For Christ, though he was in the form of God, did not regard equality with God as something to be exploited, but emptied himself, taking the form of a slave, being born in human likeness. And being found in human form, he humbled himself and became obedient to the point of death — even death on a cross.
Jesus models this perfect obedience, this perfect transformation. God becoming human, living and dying for us and, at the last, rising from the dead. The will of our Father is that we follow Jesus. Through our lives, our deaths, and, at the last, our resurrections. That we become obedient as Jesus was. That we profess our faith “not only with our lips, but in our lives,” and transform our hearts so that they may be ready to hear his call, every day and at the last day, when he will call for us as he called for Lazarus, one great final transformation.
So this week, when we are met with challenges, which we will be, and we are asking ourselves what we should do, let us remember that we do not do these things alone. We can do them as friends of Jesus. We can meet life’s challenges in obedience to him. When our faith is most alive, our every action can become wrapped up in our love for him, and his love for us.
In the words of the hymn we sang together:
“Help us, O Lord, to live
the faith which we proclaim,
that all our thoughts and words and deeds
may glorify thy name.”