Matthew 10:40-42
Saint Peter’s Westchester Square
June 28, 2026 | Eucharist
Neil Reilly, SSB
It was fifty years ago. The country was preparing to celebrate its bicentennial — two hundred years of American independence and freedom. Like this year, cities around the country were planning events. There were fireworks coast to coast, and red, white, and blue on everything. The American Freedom Train spent 1975 and 1976 touring all forty-eight contiguous states, carrying historical treasures. A flotilla sailed into New York Harbor, and up the Hudson River.
It was not a time of celebration for everyone, particularly not for LGBTQ Americans. Only seven years earlier, in 1969, a police raid on the Stonewall Inn — a gay bar in Greenwich Village — had erupted into days of resistance: the uprising that galvanized the modern gay rights movement and gave us the Pride march that will take place in New York today. By and large, the nation still criminalized being queer, and safe places for queer people were rare. Fire Island — a strip of land off the coast of Long Island — was one of those rare havens. It holds two small, predominantly gay communities: Cherry Grove, the more diverse and queer, and the Pines, the more affluent and homogenous.
Terry Warren, a drag queen, was part of the Cherry Grove community, and he felt safe on Fire Island. Warren lived his life as a woman, and today might be considered transgender. One day in the summer of 1976, he was refused service at a restaurant in the Pines because he was in drag, dressed as a woman. Because Warren lived as a woman, the refusal was not about a costume. It was a refusal of identity. If Terry was not safe here, where was he safe? Terry came as he was — and he was refused welcome for that very reason.
✦
Today’s Gospel reading is all about the Gospel imperative of welcome. “Whoever welcomes you welcomes me, and whoever welcomes me welcomes the one who sent me.” What does it mean to welcome someone like this? Jesus was always getting in trouble for the kind of people who welcomed him — people the majority culture considered sinners and outsiders. We tend to think the scandal was about the kind of people Jesus welcomed. That is surely part of it. But what truly angered the politicians and priests of the day was who Jesus received hospitality from. Who gave Jesus a place to stay. Who gave him food and drink. Necessary things. What is it like to imagine Jesus and his friends as the ones needing hospitality? Jesus as hungry and thirsty? Jesus as needing welcome? Jesus in the position of Terry Warren?
✦
My order, the Society of the Siblings at Bethany, tries to answer Jesus’ command to welcome and be welcomed — the command made so clear in today’s gospel. We are named after three of Jesus’ friends, siblings who lived together at Bethany: Martha, Mary, and Lazarus. Their home was one of the places Jesus loved to return to for rest and refreshment. It sat just on the margin of the big city, and there was something marginal about its occupants’ identities. It was a household led by a woman, Martha, despite the presence of a man, Lazarus. Not an impossibility in the first century, but certainly unusual. Despite societal norms, they had clearly chosen each other over a more typical life. It doesn’t seem like any of them was married or has children, instead living together as siblings.
Jesus clearly felt welcomed here, in this odd place. Welcomed for who he was. Jesus’ friends at Bethany recognized Jesus for who he was. After the death of her brother Lazarus, Martha said to Jesus, “I know that God will give you whatever you ask of him.” This is the recognition Jesus speaks of in today’s reading from Matthew — the same recognition Terry Warren craved fifty years ago on Fire Island. Jesus asks us to welcome prophets as prophets, the righteous as the righteous, the little ones as little ones. In other words, he expects us to welcome people as they are. Whatever their status.
More challenging, perhaps: Jesus asks us to meet people as we are. This, too, was clear at the house in Bethany. When Jesus came to Bethany after the death of Lazarus, he did not expect each of his friends to meet him where he was. When, in her grief, Martha argued that Jesus could have saved Lazarus, Jesus argued with Martha. When, in her grief, Mary wept over the death of Lazarus, Jesus wept with Mary. And when death separated Jesus from his closest friend, Lazarus, he called out of the grave. What a scandalous welcome!
✦
We are at a uniquely good moment to examine welcome in our society. Are we meeting people where they are? Are we ready to be met where we are? Not only is today Pride Sunday; it is also the start of the week that ends with the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. It is no secret that our country has failed to live up to the promise of welcome in that declaration — the promise that all people are created equal, endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights: life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
Queer people are painfully aware of that failure. The pride march that takes place today is a protest of that failure — a failure that reaches well beyond the queer community and touches so many others. People of color have experienced that failure. Women have experienced that failure. Our migrant siblings, journeying to this country because of this 250 year old promise, are experiencing the failure in a particularly painful way right now. These marches are hopeful — dreams in action, grasping at the very welcome America promised at her founding. They are prayers, even: “thy kingdom come, thy will be done.” Prayers that America will embody the scandalous welcome of its founding.
✦
I wonder who Jesus would be staying with this week. Who would be welcoming him? We know it would scandalize the politicians and the priests! How do we practice the welcome Jesus commands in today’s reading? A scandalous welcome — one that asks us to set aside our judgments and see the prophet as the prophet, the righteous as the righteous, the little ones as the little ones.
The response of Terry Warren’s friends to his refusal of service in the Fire Island Pines is a kind of living parable of how we might practice Jesus’ scandalous welcome. When they heard what had happened to Terry, they were watching the July 4 flotilla on television from their house in Cherry Grove. They did not all understand exactly what Terry had experienced. But they knew that his not being welcomed was wrong — and they chose solidarity, humility, and (most importantly, I think) curiosity as their response.
Warren’s friends from Cherry Grove dressed in drag in solidarity with him. Many of them, though queer, did not share Terry’s gender identity. They did not normally dress this way. But they chose to walk — somewhat literally — in Terry’s shoes, as a sign that Terry was not alone, and as a way of understanding what he had experienced. Inspired by the flotilla in the Hudson, they staged an “invasion” of the Pines by boat to protest the refusal of service. Every year since, for 50 years, the invasion has been repeated on July 4. It has grown into a celebration attended by hundreds of queer people and allies, who arrive on ferries chartered from Cherry Grove to the Pines. A yearly opportunity to live into, and transform, the promise of our country’s founding, to step outside of comfort zones and embody a boundary breaking welcome.
✦
The invitation is open to everyone. Whether or not you are queer — whether or not you belong to any identity for whom America is not yet a welcome — you can make the choice Terry’s friends made. Solidarity. You can choose to be with, as Jesus is with us. Put on the proverbial clothes — the drag, if you will — of the person you are trying to understand. Walk, literally, in their shoes. Humility. Set aside, as best you can, your own discomfort. You don’t have to have understood their experience first; the friends didn’t. Curiosity. Face it all with curiosity. Listen to understand, not to respond — as hard as that is. Meet people the way that Jesus met Martha, Mary and Lazarus. Be ready, as best you can, to be met that way as well. Right where you are, as vulnerable as that might be.
✦
We do not climb up to the presence of God. God reaches down to us — and the door is our own vulnerability, our willingness to be welcomed in our weakness. This downward way is not easy. We are surrounded by a call for upward mobility, to climb up to success and achievement. But, as Henri Nouwen wrote: “real and total freedom is only found through downward mobility. The Word of God came down to us and lived among us as a slave… The whole life of Jesus of Nazareth was a life in which all upward mobility was resisted.” We see exactly that in what Terry’s friends did for him.
It is in us being welcomed in our weakness that Jesus is welcomed — and therefore the Father who sent him. “Whoever welcomes you welcomes me, and whoever welcomes me welcomes the one who sent me.” Jesus names first the welcome of the prophet, then of the righteous, and finally of the little ones — the ones who do not even have a cup of cold water, the most basic need for survival in his time and ours. The welcome travels downward, toward the most vulnerable.
Queer people live this descent — this daily exposure — not occasionally but constantly. As your pastor, the Rev. Liz Edman, has written, this is like being dropped daily “into a deep pool of water,” having to “learn to swim,” to “anticipate the shock,” to “navigate the cold spots.” “Day in and day out,” she writes, queer people “risk our lives in order to feel, to touch. We put the most vulnerable aspects of ourselves on the line.” And this is exactly where the sacred is at work: God is visible, she says, “when queer people courageously speak our truth to a world torn by ambivalence, to people who fear the touch of another, of God, but who want it, who need it, fiercely.”
This, of course, is not only the queer condition — it is the Christian condition: the call to put oneself, as Mother Liz puts it, “intentionally in the path of love… laying one’s soul bare to the agony and ecstasy of God’s touch.” The vulnerability queer people live daily is the vulnerability the gospel asks of all of us — a vulnerability necessary to receive, and to give, the radical, scandalous welcome Jesus commands in today’s Gospel.
✦
Stonewall — the uprising that launched the queer rights movement, commemorated in today’s Pride March — began exactly fifty-seven years ago today. June 28, 1969. At Stonewall, queer people refused to be unwelcome. How vulnerable it must have felt, to stand that night against those who called queer lives scandalous. But I think that is exactly what Jesus asks of us in today’s Gospel.
I pray that this Pride Sunday, and this week approaching Independence Day, we might all feel called — as those brave, unlikely patriots did fifty-seven years ago — to embrace this vulnerability. To put aside our certainty and our fear, and to pick up curiosity, so that we can begin to understand one another.
May God grant us a spirit of radical, scandalous welcome this Pride Sunday, and bless this nation with the strength to fulfill its promise to all who seek welcome on our shores. Amen.