Luke 16:19–31

Luke 16:19-31
The Church of the Atonement
September 28, 2025 | Morning Prayer, Proper 21
Neil D. Reilly, SSB


“If they do not listen to Moses and the prophets, neither will they be convinced even if someone rises from the dead.”

In the name of God ✠ The One, Holy and Undivided Trinity. Amen.

Good morning, Atonement! It is so good to worship God and feast on God’s word with you this morning. We worship a God who creates by speaking, a God whose word became flesh in his son, our Saviour. Though I always miss the Eucharist when I don’t get to celebrate it in community on a Sunday, I also feel certain that Jesus is present here this morning in and as that God’s word.

That being said I wasn’t sure if we’d actually make it here this morning at all! I’m not sure if you have heard this in the news but a frighteningly large portion of American evangelical Christians were absolutely convinced that last Tuesday would be the rapture! They thought that those Christians worthy enough would be snapped up in a twinkling and saved, leaving the rest to eternal judgement or something like that.

✦

The rapture is one of those beliefs that takes parables like today’s Gospel literally but not seriously. Parables are meant to be taken seriously: they have real application for our lives today, just as they did for their first audience. But they can’t be taken literally: they are not specific advice about the specific circumstances in the story. We know, for instance, that the parable of the woman and the lost coin isn’t teaching us about house keeping, just as the parable of the lost sheep doesn’t provide sensible instructions for caring for farm animals. In parables, as in folk tales, the content is different from the message. Just as the fable of the tortoise and the hare is not really about turtles and rabbits, the story we just heard is not really about eternal reward for some and eternal punishment for others.

But today’s Gospel trips us up. We often take the story literally, and not seriously. We read it as though its contents are its message. When we do this, we get a story a bit like what we’d hear if we turn on the news right now: Our side is the good side, the deserving side! Because we’ve done good, we deserve good. We’re special. But that other side, they’ve missed the mark. Because they haven’t done good, they do not deserve good. This is a story of division. A story of “us” “in here” versus “them” “out there.”

I’ll admit, this is an attractive story. It’s the kind of story I think some of our sisters and brothers in Christ who awaited the rapture last Tuesday hoped in. A story of a chosen few who, because of right belief and good behaviour, are swept away to “Abraham’s bosom.” Wouldn’t it be nice to be among those chosen. But I contend that, though this may be engaging as an ancient morality play, it is not what Jesus is saying. It is not the Gospel. Today’s gospel parable is not a story of division, it is a story of reversal. This is not a story of future punishment or reward, it’s present good news, particularly for the poor.

When we take this parable seriously, one of the first things we see is the many contrasts. A rich man dressed in purple and linen and Lazarus covered in sores. The rich man feasting every day and Lazarus begging for crumbs. The rich man dead and buried and Lazarus dead and carried away by angels. Perhaps most strikingly, the rich man un-named and this pathetic man at the gate given the name “God has helped,” “Elʻāzār,” Lazarus. The only thing they seem to have in common is that they died, as we all do.

Fundamental to most of the literal readings of the story as a morality play about eternal reward and punishment is the contrast between these two characters and their behaviour. Who is deserving, and who is undeserving. A first century audience would have found the name-less rich man’s behaviour objectionable. As a wealthy member of his community and a descendent of Abraham, it would have been his obligation to care for the poor, as the Law of Moses demanded. The Letter to Timothy that we heard today echoes this idea: “Those who in the present age are rich… do good… be rich in good works, generous, and ready to share… For the love of money is the root of all kinds of evil.” To pass by Lazarus each day and do nothing ignores the Law of Moses, as it ignores the Gospel. So perhaps we can say the rich man is “undeserving.”

How about Lazarus, though? Can we say he is “deserving?” What do we really know about him? He doesn’t do or say anything righteous. In fact he doesn’t say anything at all. The most intimate thing we learn about him is that he “longed to satisfy his hunger,” but he’s never described as doing anything other than laying at the gate. All we know for certain is that he is poor, he is hungry, and he is sick. So this is not a neat story of who deserves heaven and who deserves hell. Jesus rarely tells such stories. Nevertheless, heaven and hell are where our parable takes us.

In the most folk-tale-like portion of the story, we see heaven and hell lined up with a clear sight line between. Just as clearly as Lazarus would have seen the rich man from his place laying at his gate, the rich man now looks up from hell and sees Lazarus in heaven. “Father Abraham,” the rich man begs, “have mercy on me, and send Lazarus to dip the tip of his finger in water and cool my tongue, for I am in agony in these flames.” Abraham does not judge the rich man when he denies his request. He states as fact that their lots have switched. Lazarus was once poor and is now rich. The rich man was once rich and is now poor. Abraham says this is simply the way things are: “between you and us a great chasm has been fixed…no one can cross.”

Again, this is not a depiction of Jesus’ ideas about the afterlife. Jesus isn’t telling us what to expect about heaven or hell or how to get there. This is a parable, so that’s the content, not the message. The message is one of reversal. A message of vindication for the poor. A message, as Lazarus’ name tells us, that isn’t anything we can do that will help us, “God has helped.”

Some people think, and I agree, that this Lazarus is somehow related to the Lazarus at Bethany, the brother of Martha and Mary. One of the reasons for this belief is that the Lazarus of Bethany did in fact, as the rich man in our story asks, come back from the dead. Here, the rich man hopes that, if Lazarus returns, it will convince his family to live moral lives, so they can be spared the fate he now suffers. “Father Abraham,” the rich man says, “if someone from the dead goes to them, they will repent.” Abraham’s words, delivered by Jesus in this parable, should be chilling to us. “If they do not listen to Moses and the prophets, neither will they be convinced even if someone rises from the dead.”

There is yet another Lazarus, another “Elʻāzār,” in scripture, who bears mentioning here. In Genesis, when God made his covenant with Abraham and Sarah, God came to Abraham in a dream and told him he would be the father of a great nation. Abraham told God “I continue childless, and the heir of my house is Eliezer (or Lazarus) of Damascus. You have given me no offspring, so a slave born in my house is to be my heir.” God brought him outside and delivered unbelievable news, “‘Look toward heaven and count the stars, if you are able to count them.’ Then God said to him, ‘So shall your descendants be.’ And Abraham believed the Lord, and the Lord reckoned it to him as righteousness.”

The rich man in today’s parable is a descendant of that same Abraham, a member of that nation. Reasonably certain of his deserving status. Firm in his belief that he was righteous and chosen. Some theologians believe that Jesus hoped we would see Eliezer, the passed over slave, when we see Lazarus at the gate. A poor man, passed over by Abraham’s descendant, as he had been passed over by Abraham. The one no man would help, but whom “God will help.” “Elʻāzār.” Equal now to Abraham in paradise.

Our faith is rightly founded on the hope of the resurrection. But if we begin to believe our faith makes us special or chosen, we have missed the point of the resurrection. Jesus came for Lazarus, for the one that no one would help. Jesus did not come to divide us into “us” and “them,” but when he finds us divided, he is inevitably with “them.” A vindication for the poor. A great reversal. Very good news.

If we believe something about resurrection but ignore God’s will for the poor, we will fulfill father Abraham’s warning. “If they do not listen to Moses and the prophets, neither will they be convinced even if someone rises from the dead.”

Amen.