John 15:12–17

John 15:12-17
Saint John the Divine
May 23, 2025 | Holy Eucharist
Neil D Reilly


In his dialogue “On Friendship,” Roman statesman and orator Cicero described friendship as the best thing a person can experience. Friendship, he wrote, is natural, arising from creation itself. Rome in the first century BCE was a very different place to be a friend. First of all, there weren’t as many institutions, at least as you and I would consider them. Need money? You’re probably going to ask a friend, not a bank. Need someone to speak up for you in a court. You’re as likely to ask a friend as a lawyer.

So when Cicero says that friendship is its own reward, he doesn’t mean that friendship isn’t about mutual benefits, he means that friendship is first and foremost about the affection between you and your friend. Benefits certainly follow, and we should enjoy them. What governs that affection? Cicero lived through the murder of Julius Caesar by men who were considered his friends, so he’s careful to point out that there are many people who say they are friends who are not. True friends must be virtuous. Friendship, he argues, is impossible between people who are not “good.”

Virtue was very important in Roman society, and to Cicero in particular. He said virtue should be considered the very highest value, with friendship a close second. And from that virtue and affection arise benefits in friendship that cannot be found anywhere else. Cicero tells us: If your friend is rich, you are not poor. If your friend is strong, you are not weak. If your friend is alive, you are not dead. Friendship is the height of humanity.

✦

People still feel this way. Close friends are still rare, most Americans have five or less, and friendship is counted as more precious than marriage, children or wealth. Friendship clearly still matters. And it mattered to Jesus, too. “You are my friends if you do what I command you…I have called you friends, because I have made known to you everything that I have heard from my Father. You did not choose me but I chose you.” Jesus offers us his friendship. He offered everything he had, everything he knew, to his friends, and asked them to do the same for each other. While making it clear that they did not choose him, he chose them, he elevated them to a place of equality in their relationship.

✦

Aelred, a 12th century English abbot, says that this changes everything about friendship. Aelred agrees with Cicero’s definitions but says that friendship is not just natural, it is a particular gift of God in Christ. Aelred also disagrees with earlier Christian thinkers who contended that friendship could be a distraction, that our love for each other could keep us from love for God. On the contrary, Aelred teaches that today’s passage from John invites us to a new understanding of friendship. Friendship is the path to unity of all kinds. True friends share not only affections, but souls! And so in loving each other, we begin to ascend a ladder of love for Jesus. The perfection of our love for our friends is the love of God.

We live today in the fruit of that friendship. The friendship of the apostles, passed down, friend to friend, affection to affection is the church. Sharing in those things that the Father told Jesus, that Jesus told his friends. That’s what we are doing today. As Jesus offered himself, all in all, to his friends. He asks us to do the same.

Aelred knew this was a risk. He knew this was hard. Even in his monastic context, he spoke of the fear that came with making a new friend, hoping they would be someone he could trust, someone who would trust him. Feeling the stirring of affections, and worrying that he would be hurt if he opened up about his hopes, fears and dreams. The fear of rejection and loneliness. But Aelred counseled that it is worth the risk, and that Jesus, as the perfect friend, is the perfect model for how to be friends with one another. Jesus, who knew loneliness, is the perfect companion for overcoming it.

Here and now, in our humanity, if we are lucky we will have a few close friends. Five or less, in the US. But Aelred’s vision of sanctified friendship lifts us beyond these temporal connections into a unity with one another and with Christ. “The friendship we experience here on earth to which we admit but a few will pour out and over all and flow back to God from all, for God will be all in all.”